Well once I found out that I wasn't saving the configuration file, I got a little closer. Of course now the pin isn't recognized.
Code:
[charles@localhost ~]$ msynctool --sync BlackBerry
Synchronizing group "BlackBerry"
Member 2 of type evo2-sync just connected
Member 3 of type evo2-sync just connected
Member 4 of type evo2-sync just connected
Member 1 of type barry-sync had an error while connecting: Unable to find PIN 140b328
Member 3 of type evo2-sync just disconnected
Member 4 of type evo2-sync just disconnected
Member 2 of type evo2-sync just disconnected
All clients have disconnected
The sync failed: Unable to connect one of the members
Error while synchronizing: Unable to connect one of the members