That's exactly what I was wondering about Gnome 3 GoinEasy9. It just feels like half the functionality of Gnome 2 has been taken away and nothing useful added. The launch dock in Gnome 3 isn't new; I have AWN dock in Gnome 2. The screen that shows all the applications isn't new; I can select "all applications" in my Gnome 2 menu. Plus in Gnome 2 I can easily change themes and/or a myriad of desktop settings that I don't see in Gnome 3. And it does indeed take more clicks to do most things.
I imagine when Gnome 2 came out there were similar discussions, but we are supposed to be advancing, not regressing. Gnome devs seem to want to compete with Enlightenment, but I see no need to do so.
Just my $.02


