PDA

View Full Version : Buying new wireless card... Suggestions?


Kjartan
2007-12-24, 10:40 PM CST
I'm currently looking at a Proxim Orinoco card... Priced at about 80 some bucks from CDW. I've heard good things about the Atheros chipsets running on Unix/Linux kernels.

Price isn't an issue... But does anyone have any other suggestions about a card that will work with Fedora 8 right out of the box? (meaning I won't have to monkey with firmware, etc)

If so, I'd appreciate any and all!

SDGathman
2007-12-25, 08:51 PM CST
> does anyone have any other suggestions about a card that will work with Fedora 8 right out of the box?

I can tell you what doesn't work. The b43 (Broadcom) driver works for 10 minutes or so, then disconnects for a few minutes, then connects again for another 10 minutes. You can get some work done, but it is *not* fun. It is not the WAP, because other laptops work fine. The rt73usb (ralink) driver connects for about 1 minute, then gets usb errors until you power cycle the USB key. No, it is not hardware - everyone else has the same problem. The zd1211rw (Zydas, e.g. HWU54G) driver used to work perfectly through kernel release 63. Suddenly, in kernel release 85, support has been complete removed! Is there any working wireless left in FC8? I can pick up a prism based device (Linksys) from Walmart to see if it might work.
But I am very discouraged.

<pityparty>
EL5 and Centos were working with Zydas wireless, but all the new laptops have VIA (horrible video drivers), Nvidia (decent but proprietary), or Intel X3100 video (documented, but still experimental and buggy in linux). So I was forced to install FC8 to get an X3100 driver that works at all (returned an Nvidia based laptop that had hardware problems causing freezeups). And now there is no working wireless support. So my wife will have to keep using her reliable but slow 600Mhz M700 at work.
</pityparty>

SDGathman
2007-12-26, 10:46 PM CST
Just plugged in a pcmcia rtl8180 wireless. Works in EL5 with driver I built from source. Gets kernel Oops in kernel-2.6.23.9-85.fc8. So that's four wireless devices that don't work. I would go back to EL5, except there is no support for X3100 display that comes with all new Intel laptops now. I would buy a used laptop if I could find one.