PDA

View Full Version : Wouldums wike a wittle wubi?


schwim
22nd September 2007, 09:08 PM
I dedicate the following to Dan and Seve. Seve because his post count now exceeds God's and I fear that he can actually bend time so I want to stay on his good side. Dan because he does incredibly cool things like sends you Fedora installs when your internet connection precludes you from being able to do so yourself. I can never do things like help them on the forum, so the fact that they can get a chuckle out of my inability to turn a computer on is the best reward I can muster.

Before we get into the nuts and bolts, you need to know that you should take this as a every-man's record of the install and thoughts pertaining to it in that light. I'm the guys that you look at and figure shouldn't be here. I fail at most of the things I try to do when using linux as a desktop and my statistics aren't improving that much over the years.

That's why I wanted to try it though. I'd never been willing to dual-boot one of my machines, so I thought this being an application based alternative would cool to try. Which brings me to my first point of the install. You're going to end up dual-booting :D. There's no way around it.

I downloaded the .exe installer from wubi-installer.org and ran it. It asked me a minimal amount of questions (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/wubi2.jpg). Upon answering them, it immediately began downloading the 875mb install. During the process, you get to choose which version of Ubuntu you would like to install. I chose UbuntuStudio. It will rotate mirrors when attempting to connect, so if you get a slow download, cancel and restart the installer. Last night, I got 20kbps, which timed out over the night. This morning on restart, I got 175kbps.

After download, it tells you that you need to restart. On restart, you have the option of choosing the OS to boot.... If your computer will detect your keyboard when outside of the OS :). My USB keyboard is not recognized on startup, so I had to get under the desk with a standard keyboard and use it to choose Ubuntu. Once I did that, I could unplug the keyboard and watch the proceedings with facination.

On first boot, the real install begins. I didn't have the savvy to snap any screens, but It "retrieved", "installed" and "configured" a lot of applications. It took about 20 minutes before it was done. Once finished, it automatically rebooted, so back under the desk I go with my keyboard :) After choosing Ubuntu again, I unplugged and had a seat.

My first (and most notable) impressions are these:

1) I didn't really have to do anything, other than choose a username and password. I didn't get asked to register at any site, I didn't get asked what kind of internet connection I used, nothing. It simply rebooted and I had a desktop that, so far as I can tell, everything worked on.

2) It strikes me as being very polished (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/wubi4.png) in regards to out of the box graphics and themes. I like the black default theme that came with UbuntuStudio, and don't think I'd even try to change it.

3) It acts like an OS, and not a Windows install of another OS. I know to most of you, this is a given, but to the uninitiated, when reading wubi's site, it seems like you'll get to Ubuntu from Windows. Because of that, I pictured Wubi being very laggy. After initial startup, processor usage dropped to normal(5%) and memory use dropped as well (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/wubi6.png). I guess on initial start, it had some things to take care of.

The only thing that confused me so far? I never set a root password. There obviously was a root password, as it often asked me for it, but I had no idea what it was :). I couldn't find mention of it in the docs somewhere, and I would think that this is something you want to take care of on install. For instance, no upgrades for me! (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/wubi8.png)

So I needed to find a way to get my updates and such. Wubi-installer.org sent me to wikis and support forums. One of the support forums provided this thread (http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=540396&highlight=root+password). I was sad to hear tht Wubi didn't use a root password, since it wouldn't let me update without the root password that it didn't use.

My next step was to figure out how to change the root password. This site (http://linux.byexamples.com/archives/183/change-password/) and the instructions on using sudo(not sudu, as I was typing it) got me a root password (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/wubi9.png). I can say with complete surety that I do not have a family member that could have done this.

A pretty neat package, all in all. As is the case with any support forum, the wubi forums has some very angry people(slow disk access, wubi being broken by certain package updates) and some people who view it as the devil's OS, but in my very limited time, I've been impressed by it.

If anyone wants me to do some tests or try something, just let me know and I'd be happy to if I can.

Added bonus? My screensaver worked out of the box! :D

thanks,
json

Dan
23rd September 2007, 01:13 AM
*Shakes head and chuckles!*

Thanks schwim! I take it DVDs and such work straight away? No codec search, no cryptic file to locate and install?


Dan

rerushg
23rd September 2007, 01:22 AM

Whew. The spell is broken. Didn't want to violate the sanctity of this thread until at least one of the "honorees" showed up. :D
Nice piece of work, schwim. Nice review.
Now: The "utility value" of Wubi is a bit lost on me. What does it do that I could not do as well (better?) with conventional methods?

schwim
23rd September 2007, 03:29 AM
Thanks schwim! I take it DVDs and such work straight away? No codec search, no cryptic file to locate and install?

Hi there Dan,

I tried to check to see if I could import a .wav off of a cd into Audacity and export to mp3, but I couldn't view the contents of the audio cd. I can view a data cd without issue, but when I put the audio album in, it gave me an error (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/cderror1.png). I haven't found out why yet, so I've not gotten to play with audio to date in it.

DVD's:

I can tell you part of the process:

1) I inserted the DVD and it recognized it, asking me if I wanted to retrieve the correct codec (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/dvd1.png)

2) It found the codec. (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/dvd2.png)

3) When I tried to select it for download, it let me know that I was downloading stuff I probably shouldn't have. (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/dvd3.png)

4) I confirmed that I was a bad person, and it allowed me to select & download (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/dvd4.png)

5) I reinserted the dvd and was rewarded with the following screenshot (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/dvd5.png)

So in short, I can't really tell you how it handles media, since I can't get any media to shake hands with the OS ;)


Whew. The spell is broken. Didn't want to violate the sanctity of this thread until at least one of the "honorees" showed up.
Nice piece of work, schwim. Nice review.
Now: The "utility value" of Wubi is a bit lost on me. What does it do that I could not do as well (better?) with conventional methods?


Hi there rerushg,

I don't think there is a benefit. I believe that this is going to appeal to the very brand new user that is afraid of doing something wrong but wants to try linux. It doesn't ask you a damn thing, but instead hands you a desktop when it's done. New users have a problem sometimes taking the dive, and when you visit the wubi site, you come away thinking that you're just installing another application that can be uninstalled at any time. We know that this isn't true, but I think it is a simple mind-set manipulation. There are plenty of users on the wubi forum that can no longer boot win or ubu, so the dual boot risks are still there.

Just my thoughts, there very well may be very good reasons to use it, but that's the only thing I can think of.

thanks,
json

Seve
23rd September 2007, 04:57 AM
Hello schwim:
Nice work :)

How well does video work and are you able to use 3rd party video drivers ?

Thanks

Seve

schwim
23rd September 2007, 05:36 AM
hi there seve,


IRT existing video: Again, I've not taxed it much, but it seems to be handling everything as good as can be expected(3d screensavers bumpity bump if it's a busy one, etc.). Better than the stock drivers did on my Fedora install, for sure though.

IRT updating drivers: I've found no hard information one way or the other, but I have found two conflicting insinuations:

1) ago(I guess the dev of Wubi) states in the FAQ on the Ubuntu forums that once the installer has done it's job, you're simply dealing with a normal install of Ubuntu, and should use that forum to troubleshoot any issues post-install. This leads me to believe that it would be as easy to install as on any other Ubu platform.

2) Then we have the actual Wubi support forums. There's not a lot, but quite a few people who state that they broke Wubi because of nightly updates/install of 'X'/3rd party replacements. These posts lead me to believe that maybe it's not such a great idea to mess with some of the files in Wubi. I wouldn't think that video drivers would be one of the things I would need to worry about though...

Once/If I get the cd/dvd thing figured out, I'll move on to trying a few different things.

thanks,
json

schwim
25th September 2007, 06:45 AM
Well, adding all of the codecs and dirty stuff solved my problem of not being able to play a dvd, but for some reason, I still can't do ANYTHING with an audio cd. This includes simply opening it in a file browser.

It may be just me, but the install of the dirty bits seemed more of a hassle to me than when dealing with Fedora. I guess some parts were easier, but there was very little in Ubu to tell you what you needed to do. Actually, nothing. In Fedora, I would get errors telling me that something wasn't supported because it wasn't "clean". In Ubuntu, I just got an error box.

Regardless, a few packages in the app installer and some terminal commands got me the dvd, fonts, mp3, vid codecs and all the other stuff that isn't in the default install. They did package most of that all into one install package. I only had to install gstreamer modules afterwords.

All wrapped up in one handy package (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/dirty.png)
DVD now plays (http://personal.schwim.net/images/share/wubi/dvd_ok.png)

If I can get the cd part working, I thought I might do some benchmarks for the hell of it to see if Wubi really slows down the disk access that much.

thanks,
json

schwim
25th September 2007, 07:22 AM
How well does video work and are you able to use 3rd party video drivers?

Hi there Seve,

Tonight I decided to go ahead and try installing them. I was successful, with the following steps:

1) go into synaptic and download nvidia-glx package.

2) In the terminal, type the following: sudo nvidia-xconfig

3) Restart X.

I now have working nvidia drivers on the computer, and you can really tell a difference.

I've got a 7600GS and I didn't know if I needed the nvidia-GLX or nvidia-GLX_new package, but the non-new seems to be working a-ok.

thanks,
json